Today's post has multiple parts so here goes
1. Comments
2. Chapter 4 & 5 extras
3. Picture Post
4. New Chapter
- Playlist
feel free to guide yourself accordingly
Comments
Georgia said...
July said...
This was my favorite chapter ever I am so addicted again. This was lovely.
FIRST ! ! !
FIRST ! ! !
Thank you
NYgirl said...
Kill Sofia
Kill Tomas
Let Tomas get Severine Pregnant
Make it a Dream
Blow upNew York City
But do not let them move toNew Jersey !
Kill Tomas
Let Tomas get Severine Pregnant
Make it a Dream
Blow up
But do not let them move to
That bad, huh ?
This chapter was very emotional for me I literally felt every emotion even the sassiness (as I call it)of Severine. I really loved this chapter also.
Sassiness, I like that
Another great, ending Linda I am totally sitting here finding meaning in it and I have to be at school in the morning. I too am totally addicted to this.
Although I hate the JS version of "These Boots"
Although I hate the JS version of "These Boots"
I know but it just fit.
One of your characters names is Julia ? Is that another slip ? Is that what you are going to take slack for ?
I really like this chapter too. I couldn't believe the Stranger was a real song, it fit the story perfectly. You are doing so good. I know I said we shouldn't acknowlegde it but, it's creepy how our stories are taking similar routes, some you are not even aware of.
I really like this chapter too. I couldn't believe the Stranger was a real song, it fit the story perfectly. You are doing so good. I know I said we shouldn't acknowlegde it but, it's creepy how our stories are taking similar routes, some you are not even aware of.
I know right ! I mean you have no idea and I thought Juliana’s nickname was Julie. There are a few more things you might notice. I was going to take the bruise covering make-up out when I saw it in UL but I didn’t. reading UL also made me realize I should mention a free clinic.
Does Severine not like Tomas for the reasons she said or because Tomas didn't pick her ? I mean she did try to do him.
She doesn’t like him because he married Sofia and maybe she is jealous, I don’t know
Okay, someone said it last time I totally think Adam is a prince, he totally, totally is. I am seconded that calling.
Funny you say this
Another beautiful ending !
Is it hard for you to make the endings ?
Is their any greater significance in the ending ? I feel like I don't understand the last line.
Is it hard for you to make the endings ?
Is their any greater significance in the ending ? I feel like I don't understand the last line.
Not, really. It was just showing how passionately he was kissing her.
Oh, also in United Light, Brad's origininal name was Derek but I changed it because I think of Derek as a name for handsome young men (Derek from Swan Princess, Derek Hough . . . ).
... I may have had on wine cooler tonight.
... I may have had on wine cooler tonight.
Derek Hough, Shawna he is barley legal, Lol
^^
Never let friends, drink and type.
I hate when you leave subtle hints about something you did but, I will go ahead and guess. You've talked aboutSofia beinf affected by her rape in tiny ways but, now you've put it in a more emotional way. I have no clue.
Also I think when you said you will get slack for something it's eitherSofia 's need to clean or Sofia apologizing to Tomas instead of the other way around.
You pulled some heartstrings, Linda
When I wrote that I was actually talking about the book.
Judging by the tattoo and--even though I have no clue why anyone would carry something as big as a revolver around-- the gun. I would say you are trying to make me lose 100$.
Oh well, I will take what I can get.
Never let friends, drink and type.
I hate when you leave subtle hints about something you did but, I will go ahead and guess. You've talked about
Also I think when you said you will get slack for something it's either
You pulled some heartstrings, Linda
When I wrote that I was actually talking about the book.
Judging by the tattoo and--even though I have no clue why anyone would carry something as big as a revolver around-- the gun. I would say you are trying to make me lose 100$.
Oh well, I will take what I can get.
No, it’s nothing content wise and I’m not trying to make you lose anything.
^^
I find it interesting that Tomas and Sofia have set up those rules but, they don't seem to be keeping up with them.I'm just afraid what will happen when Tomas meets Adam. Oh, wait I think you are going to pull a Sixth Sense . . . wait, can I call that ?
So, his brother's SO name is Julia. With a J, right ?
That's another 10 points, which is great because the Sarah Conner Chronicles 3rd season and the first season of Castle comes out this week.
I find it interesting that Tomas and Sofia have set up those rules but, they don't seem to be keeping up with them.I'm just afraid what will happen when Tomas meets Adam. Oh, wait I think you are going to pull a Sixth Sense . . . wait, can I call that ?
So, his brother's SO name is Julia. With a J, right ?
That's another 10 points, which is great because the Sarah Conner Chronicles 3rd season and the first season of Castle comes out this week.
I don’t know how to respond to this anymore but there are two reasons I picked Julia Roberts.
^^ ^^^
You guys ARE idiots
You guys ARE idiots
Thank you !
Stuff like Sofia thinking Tomas had the dead cat are moments that make me want to look up and see the scene taking place in my office, er I mean living room, lol ! Just the way it was written was so fantastic. I usually am not a commenter but I had to come and speak out.
LOL, you guys are funny
Cari said...
His brother's name is Amadaeus, that is timeless. Is their a story behind it.I love Adam's family, they are funny and sweet. I read the song before listening and it was just as I imagined, I love this chapter.
No, I just wanted them to have similar names even though Amadeus is German. I originally wanted him to have a name like John Adams or Patrick Adams.
Sofia said Heath Ledger makes clothes, I was ROFL that is so funny to me
Was it ? I just thought they looked similar, I’m usually not good with the humor even though I’m hilarious in RL.
How come Severine didn't get a James Bond joke ? Is the bar a real place, it sounds nice.
Little known fact the martini is mentioned in the Quantum Solace movie but it hasn’t come out yet. The martini is also mention in Casino Royale but only the short story. The bar isn’t real ):
You have me so torn, I mean I want to know more about Adam but I like Tomfia. But, I feel like with the ADC he is going to die quicker. I am afraid he is going to die in Lithuania .
I want you to be torn
I feel like it's both liberating and fun that Tomas is living his dream with his business and all but, as the above said has he considered who will take over if he dies. I doubt he had health insurance pre-AIDS and now it must be sky high.
I guess, Kasey gets it.
I guess, Kasey gets it.
It’s supposed to be liberating and fun, great words.
it's strange that Tomas and Sofia are married but, they don't know about Adam or Terry. I tell my husband everything, he knows all the women I work with even though he has never met them,lol.
Why are they hiding
Why are they hiding
Good question.
I feel like I should reserve all opinions until the series is over. I feel like everytime I want this to be over you pull me back in with a moment or scene that makes me want it to go on forever.
I just want to show some love because I feel like I can't make a comment without feeling like it will be off base or something. Or me seeing something out of nothing
I just want to show some love because I feel like I can't make a comment without feeling like it will be off base or something. Or me seeing something out of nothing
I do it all the time on Shawna’s blog, I don’t expect comments but I respond because want people to know that I read their comment.
Heidi said...
I'm surprised no one has mentioned the Derek-Sofia scene.
I found that very emotional too. I actually felt her pain, I was right there fighting with her. I myself love reading and having intellectual conversation that is civilized but, I wish Tomas raped him with that revolver. I hate men, no people like that so much.
I found that very emotional too. I actually felt her pain, I was right there fighting with her. I myself love reading and having intellectual conversation that is civilized but, I wish Tomas raped him with that revolver. I hate men, no people like that so much.
I wanted her to be a fighter
^^
You have +1 on that comment, Heidi.
So, Roberts is his last name so he said I'll just want to be called Robert . . . who does that ? That is either cute or funny. Unless it's a British thing.
You have +1 on that comment, Heidi.
So, Roberts is his last name so he said I'll just want to be called Robert . . . who does that ? That is either cute or funny. Unless it's a British thing.
He finds it hard working with a unique name but being called Roberts is a little weird so he shortned it.
I am Adam/Sofia all the way. I feel so bad for Adam because if he like Sofia and he sang that song for her, he must be hurting so much.
Is their more meaning behind the 1$ bill Severine gives him. I mean it's just a dollar but, from her.
Is their more meaning behind the 1$ bill Severine gives him. I mean it's just a dollar but, from her.
No, she was just being tongue and cheek
Was Tomas pulling a practical joke with the cat ?
I liked this chapter I can't wait to continue the journey.
I liked this chapter I can't wait to continue the journey.
Yes and No, but I don’t think they allow animals on subways. I think you can take it as you will.
I don't usually comment but, I was reading this in my doctors office and I have to say you have set the bar so high with this. It was really nice.
Thanks, I forget people can read things on their phone.
cherry said...
Um, won't Tomas die from eating that much lipstick ? I thought that was a little odd.
I have a billion questions but, I'm sure you will answer them soon.
I have a billion questions but, I'm sure you will answer them soon.
I’ll try to answer them
I feel like they can't catch a break, it is just so tragic. I am glad Tomas helped her, like even though he was sick, he got over it to protect her.
He didn’t get over it really, he was just fighting the pain.
I just need more. That is it. Is the double spacing a new thing
No, I think it’s the formatting of the website. Each line is usually double spaced but it looks differntI’m going to see if I can fix it. I wasn’t sure how that looked
Sofytė said...
I'm sure you will answer this late but, why does Tomas call Sofia, Sofytė. Also, is their an accent in Tomas's name so it is actually
toMAS and not Tomas
toMAS and not Tomas
It’s pronounced Tomas, and I mentioned this a while back about how the Lithuanian language uses a lot of diminutives and adding ytė was one that worked well with Sofia ’s name. He was supposed to call her that earlier hince why I posted about it.
I think Tomas killed Derek, like shot him using some fancy Lithuanian Military Silencer style of shooting. He would have shot him and I'd be okay with it.
I can't imagine walking around with such bad bruises.
I can't imagine walking around with such bad bruises.
Yeah, as I was rereading I see how you would get that but that is not what happened I mean she sprayed his penis with mace, so. . .
Luna said...
Srsly, Linda if you have the real Tomas locked away somewhere I will hunt you down. I need a foreign man who will kill a guy for me.
No, sorry ):
I am finding meaning in everything from their book choices to the names,it is killing me. I mean Adam carries a guitar but, plays the piano does it mean anything ?
*brain implodes*
*brain implodes*
If it helps I can tell you that I don’t dabble to much in symbolism.
Pets have known to help cure people or make them live better maybe, Tomas will learn to like Charleston
He doesn’t not like Charleston , he just doesn’t like him
SideNote @ Jason & Joel – He doesn’t like animals . . .
Daisy said...
I am super concerened for Tomas' mother. I have always known domestic violence was bad but when you have something like Sofia 's injuries it just cracks up my heart. I think Sofia should go look for her.
Domestic Violence is an issue
It's odd, I didn't percieve him wiping his eye as crying until I read this for the 3rd time ( I admit it). Tomas really is a sensitive guy and with all the drugs you forget that. Just my thought
Yeah, I added that in as a last minute thing,
Billi said...
I really like Severine's passage. She has always come off as one dimensional but then in one paragraph I just got her. It all clicked.
Whew, I was a little concerned about switching to her POV but I felt she could tell it best.
Ella said...
This was my favorite too, it was riddled with some good quotes. I think some people will give you slack for TomFia never doing Christamas or V-day together but, I think they have more important things to do.
I mean Sofia has school and Tomas has work, but nice observation.
Chapter 4
The Plan
Okay so I mentioned that Chapter 4 was just a section. Originally Adam invites Sofia to his show when they go to lunch, then Sofia comes home to find Tomas never went to work and he had been calling her because he decided to attend the conference and went out drinking with friends.
Convention
There really was a Tattoo conference in Vilinus this September and it all just clicked, the name however is a mixture of different Tattoo convention names.
The Dresser
When writing chapter four I think the hardest part was deciding what Sofia had in her dresser drawer. The perfume bottles are what she used to keep her pills in and and the lipstick has it's own section.
Extension
The section where Tomas is speaking about what he does have an extension on it because I wanted to add some sexual tension but I didn't think it worked to well, you can read it here
Chapter 5
Severine
I was a little unsure about letting Severine have a "speaking" role but I think it's a nice way to get perspective on the other characters. I don't know if I'll do it again though.
Taking Slack
I said before that I would get slack for something and it's the fact that I put lyrics into a story, I didn't want to do it but sometimes reading the lyrics helps tell the story and the word "Angel" is in the song so I had to
Original Plan
So like I said up there orignially the whole ordeal with Tomas overdosing was not apart of the plan, it went straight from Tomas telling Sofia he was leaving to her going out and I felt like something was missing. Amadeus and Julia also were not in the final version but I was inspired by my own family to put them in and I wanted Adam to have some people on his side.
Lipstick
I think in my other scribblings I had inadvertently given Tomas a slight lipstick Fetish. Now don't be judgmental but I decided to make it come full circle in this chapter. Going back first hinted at in Free Spirts
Section one
". . . concentrating on her lips as she blew her freshly painted nail "
"He felt her cool breath on his hand and he placed his thumb on his mouth parting her full red lips"
Section three
"Watching her part her pretty pink lips just about kills me" Then in S & A , the first chapter he describes the pin-up girl ". . .the click of red heels, fish net stocking and a short skirt followed by bright red lips and dark eyes. . ."
So I did have a reason to have the lipstick in a drawer which is why when somone commented about Tomas being a vampire (he's not, btw) I had already written that he sucks the lipstick off her lips so, that's that. I'm sure if you know the history of lipstick you'll probably get a little more out of it.
Plot Hole
So, there is one plot hole that I don't think I can fill and that is Tomas is technically not an American citizen, he could have dual citizen ship but doesn't want to acknowledge his father. Just throwing that out there.
Inspiration for Adam
(Jackson Rathbone)
Inspiration for Sofia
(Ellen Page)
Amadeus Adams
Geroge Stults (w/ gray hair)
I'm still working on Julia.
I was a little unsure about letting Severine have a "speaking" role but I think it's a nice way to get perspective on the other characters. I don't know if I'll do it again though.
Taking Slack
I said before that I would get slack for something and it's the fact that I put lyrics into a story, I didn't want to do it but sometimes reading the lyrics helps tell the story and the word "Angel" is in the song so I had to
Original Plan
So like I said up there orignially the whole ordeal with Tomas overdosing was not apart of the plan, it went straight from Tomas telling Sofia he was leaving to her going out and I felt like something was missing. Amadeus and Julia also were not in the final version but I was inspired by my own family to put them in and I wanted Adam to have some people on his side.
Lipstick
I think in my other scribblings I had inadvertently given Tomas a slight lipstick Fetish. Now don't be judgmental but I decided to make it come full circle in this chapter. Going back first hinted at in Free Spirts
Section one
". . . concentrating on her lips as she blew her freshly painted nail "
"He felt her cool breath on his hand and he placed his thumb on his mouth parting her full red lips"
Section three
"Watching her part her pretty pink lips just about kills me" Then in S & A , the first chapter he describes the pin-up girl ". . .the click of red heels, fish net stocking and a short skirt followed by bright red lips and dark eyes. . ."
So I did have a reason to have the lipstick in a drawer which is why when somone commented about Tomas being a vampire (he's not, btw) I had already written that he sucks the lipstick off her lips so, that's that. I'm sure if you know the history of lipstick you'll probably get a little more out of it.
Plot Hole
So, there is one plot hole that I don't think I can fill and that is Tomas is technically not an American citizen, he could have dual citizen ship but doesn't want to acknowledge his father. Just throwing that out there.
Pictures
Sofia's Dress (DVF bought back the wrap dress)
Inspiration for Adam
(Jackson Rathbone)
Inspiration for Sofia
(Ellen Page)
Amadeus Adams
Geroge Stults (w/ gray hair)
I'm still working on Julia.
Chapter 6
Okay I promised 3 in a row and here it goes, I will take a break tomorrow and see what happens. I hope the formatting is right, I don't know why it double spaces but I went through and fixed it which helped the editing process. I always want your opinions if you have them, of course. (I don't know why this is in bold)
Playlist
I.
II.
- 1, 2,3,4 - Always Midnight - Monohan
- 5 - Collide by Howie Day
- 6,7 - Everybody - Backstreet Boys (yes ) and Realize-Colbie Calliat @ Shawna (;
- 8 - Say- John Mayer
II.
- 1 No Envy, No Fear - Joshua Radin
- 2 A song for you - Donny Hathaway
- 4,5,6, - When Love takes Over - DJ Guetta feat. Kelly Rowland



A total Adam/Sofia chapter, I found it totally refreshing. I have no idea what will come of this.
ReplyDeleteIt was like Linda said I won't put them in New Jersey but the second worst place in the world : AC, lol.
ReplyDeleteI think you are good at writing funny, when Severine said there are no old people in Las Vegas I LOLIRL.
No, that was a huge cliffhanger nooooooooooo ! I have to know what happens next. That was so unfair, it made me so mad.
ReplyDeleteONYD, the Backstreet Boys ! That song is the epitome of boy bands. That bring back memories.
ReplyDeleteLike most people have said there exist a duality between Sofia with Tomas and Adam. We don't want her to hurt Adam but most of us like Tomas too. It makes me wonder if maybe Adam can pick up where Tomas leaves off. I have to ask if Tomas and Sofia's relationship can be defined as a marriage.
Lol, I love the Backstreet boys too. It's weird I suddenly find that song more sexual than I did before. It's weird. I just want to get up and rock my body.
ReplyDeleteThe music for this chapter was great.
In a previous post you mentioned Tomas and Sofia's birthdays, will those become significant ?
ReplyDeleteGet out of my head, ahhh ! I will probably post an entry about what is going on in UL but, it is crazy the similarities our stories took on ! However I was just throwing things agaisnt the wall so, I will most likely change some details. You said I stole a song from you but, I should say I don't really like Realize for what I used it for, I meant to use Lucky by Jason Mraz. I found out Colbie wrote Realize about how she had a roomate who liked her but, never told her until later.
ReplyDeleteThis was an interesting chapter, definatley much lighter than most. I just want to see what happens next.
"He got off the plane !"
ReplyDeleteLol, jk. I liked the lightness of this chapter too and all the pop culture references you are throwing in.
I think Tomas should stay in Lithuania, he obviously is happy and has family there. I don't know much about Lithuania (like, at all) but didn't they have a revolution recently like in the 90's ? Does that have some affect on the story.
ReplyDeleteSpirits and Angels : The Musical, I loved this so much. I like all the music. Even though for some reason Collide reminds me of the Dawson's Creek Theme song.
ReplyDeleteYou are changing up the site ? I like it.
ReplyDeleteAll the people in New York City and Sofia and Adam end up in the same Thai food place ?
They were meant for each other.
I can't believe Jackson Rathbone is 24 ! I like him for Adam, although I always think of him as gay since he was in The War at Home.
ReplyDeleteJackson Rathbone was in The Cleaner and Criminal Minds and I totally see him as Tomas (even thought I know Linda has a thing for Ben Barnes.
ReplyDeleteI love Ellen Paige for Sofia though, I'd love to see her in something more serious.
You can't leave us hanging ! Nooo. I love everything Adam says, he feels so real. I still think he is hiding something.
ReplyDeleteWas Sofia asking if he was a prince for us ?
ReplyDeleteHe may not be a prince but, he is prince charming !
I love when Sofia says one thing but thinks another it is so flirty. Like :
ReplyDelete“You’re going to regret saying that one day”, I'm going to regret you saying that one day
This one was long, I'm not sure if I can handle a break. I think it is strange that Tomas and Adam have never met, I wonder what will happen when they do.
ReplyDeleteI think the fact that Sofia got married so young is one of her flaws. She hasn't had time to meet and go out with other people. She is too young to truly understand the importance of marriage, I think they both are.
ReplyDeleteI think Sofia should move in with Severine, since they are both lonely.
ReplyDeleteAre you intentionally trying to show Sofia doing more 'normal' things ? like going to movies, going to AC ?
ReplyDeleteBTW, hated the cliffhanger, it hurt so badly ! I have to know what happens next ! That ending was a true cliffhanger because it makes you think will she or wont she.
I love the painting Jardin à Sainte-Adresse, is there any significance behind choosing it ?
ReplyDeleteIt's interesting you noticed Tomas' lipstick thing and not one of us ! Especially with everyone looking for symbolism. Maybe it is more of a motif than fetish ? IDK
ReplyDeleteIs their a reason Sofia and even Severine (love that name by the way) say the word God alot ? I just noticed that.
ReplyDeleteWhy does Adam point at the closet and talk about walking out the door ? Is he drunk ? I didn't get that.
ReplyDeleteI want to give you a critical review,since you asked for it. Can I do that ?
ReplyDeleteI think you do a great job of moving the story along and moving across time rather smoothly.
I feel like Adam is perfect . . . to perfect and I feel like Tomas is flawed . . . . to flawed. I don't know.
I feel like their is a certain vaugness in Sofia and Adams relationship but maybe that is on purpose.
I think this section goes back to Angels because it is very much about Sofia.
I want to find something wrong with this but, I honestly can't. Maybe I will later (:
No one is make a guess to what Tomas has to say ?
ReplyDeleteI totally think he is moving to Lithuania or he brought someone back with him. I'm loving all the new characters.
Can you give us a tiny itsy bitsy teensy weensy hint on what is going to happen next ? It's killing me so much.
ReplyDeleteI can't believe I've gotten addicted to this.
You are funny IRL ? That's funny.
ReplyDeleteI feel like this is another one of those chapter where you are setting up for something. Am I right ?
I have a few numbers for you Miss Leigh :
Judging by your timeline starting in Miss Angel you have written about : 54,005 words
Thats about 265 pages give or take pictures
That's also
53 Fucks
44 Shits
30 Gods
22 Hells
7 Damns
♥
I understand if you need a break, but it is going to be so hard that you left us hanging !
ReplyDeleteI guess you were forced to learn some Lithuanian ? I love how Sofia can't seem to find an American guy.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if Tomas is like detained by immigration or something. I'm anxious.
I have a feeling that if (or when) Tomas finds out about Sofia and Adam he is going to be pissed.
ReplyDeleteIn an unrelated note, did Tomas ever hit Sofia ?
I love how everyone (including a musician) has a nicer apartment than Sofia !
ReplyDeleteI love the big post and I love Ellen Paige as Sofia
Can't wait for an update. You have to be 21 to gamble in Atlantic City ? Sofia can't do anything.
ReplyDeleteI've always wondered is their a reason Sofia isn't spelled Sophia and Tomas isn't spelled Thomas ?
ReplyDeleteYour almost at the 50th post, can we still expect something special ?
ReplyDelete
ReplyDelete@ Tabitha - Me neither, I'm surprised July wasn't first Lol
@ Lucy - I know but AC has the ocean and that's something, isn't it.
@ Caylen - I think it's my first cliffhanger
@ Violeta - I don't know if I can answer your questions, I don't really have the answers yet.
@ June - *breaking glass* It is filled with innuendo isn't it. . .
@ Deena - no, I just wanted to be able to keep track of thier ages.
@ Shawna - There is more ? did you notice the Shawna Harrison crossover ?
@ Topaz - I wnted it to be a little lighter.
@ princessariel - I don't think there was a war but it doesn't really play into the story, but it does a little.
@ Rita - Yeah it does, but I really like that song
@ butterfly_wings - I'm having trouble with the layout. you know what they say at first you don't succeed thai and thai again, lol. Sorry
@ Remi - I don't know, he might be.
@ Gina - Yeah, I also liked Jackson because he is a musician and yes I do have a thing for Ben Barnes. I can't wait to see him in Dorian Gray.
@ June - I don't know
@ Cherry - Actually I had written that she asked him long before you all did which is why I said that it was intersting that some of you mentioned it.
@ Loreli - Tomas & Sofia do that alot, I'd like to think communication which is a big deal in marriage is a plot device in this story.
@ Hpgirl - I can't wait either.
@ Marie - I agree with what you are saying about Sofia.
@ Wendy - Severine is lonely because she chooses to be, Sofia is the lonely in a room full of people type.
@ Daisy - Shawna inspired my cliffhangers, blame her !
@ blonde_chick - No, it's just one they happen to have at the MoMA
@ Cobi - It's a fetish , although it could be a motif.
@ Cayalites - Severine does it because she is "blond", if you will and Sofia has been spending alot of time with her.
@ Martha - He was a little hung over he meant to point at the door.
@ Wilson - It's interesting you say that, I can definelty see that. thanks.
@ Ashlyn - Cliffhanger ! !
@ Michelle - I don't have a hint, sorry
@ Joseph - Does 'God' really count ?
@ dianmond - it will be a tiny tiny one, I promise
@ Sam_L - I know, right. Like I said I'm not going to get into the immigration stuff.
@ Minnie - He's never hit her but they did get into a physical fight in Spirits.
@ Tina - I saw her in an Ad and i thought "she's perfect"
@ Shelly - I know, even though she does drink illegally
@ Lightmyway - Sofia is an Irish spelling Sophia is the Italin spelling. and Tomas is the Baltic spelling (there is also an accent but I felt it would across at latin).
@ bostongirl - maybe, IDK
Thank You for your comments